Six Of The Best – Standing Up To The Power.

JR Lott looked who really could, and did, ‘Fight The Power‘. The top six contain players from different era’s, and different styles, and while some are relatively predictable. Others will be less so:

Betway Premier League - Week Ten Preview
Who really fought ‘The Power’? Very few won even 1/3 of their clashes with the Stoke thrower. (pic: PDC/L Lustig)

Darts World’s ‘Six of the Best’ is not usually my type of writing piece. But, while researching a different article, I happened upon a review Phil ‘The Power’ Taylor. It was interesting, to recall, that over the years only Rob Cross has a majority of competitive wins against Phil (1-0) and even that was in their only encounter.

So who else performed best and against the player many regard as the GOAT? dartsdatabase.com offered some clues. Appropriately, we decided that six encounters was the minimum to give a fair reflection. Unluckily, Keegan Brown misses out despite having a 40% win record over five encounters.

The top six contain players from different era’s, and different styles, and while some are relatively predictable. Other will be less so:

Six: Chizzy (Win rate 28%).

Dave Chisnall has a very solid record vs Phil. Although twenty eight percent may not seem very high it’s close to one win in three, and includes some superb moments. Chizzy defeated ‘The Power’ in their first encounters, both on the Pro Tour and TV. Dave’s victory at the 2012 World Championship was quite the shock to watching audiences, although those closer to the game, thought it ‘on the cards’. It is to be noted that Chizzy is a huge 180 hitter and can produce devastating scoring spells. (32 Matches).

Five: Gary Anderson (Win rate 20%).

The Flying Scotsman‘s record,vs Phil, stretches as far back as 2007 when he won their debut encounter in the World Darts Trophy. Phil reversed this a few weeks later, at the Grand Slam of Darts, and held the upper hand for the next four years. Between 2011 and 2017 Gary inched closer and won a higher and higher percentage of their matches. His 2015 World Championship victory, in the final, over The Power was, perhaps, the high-point. Anderson too is a huge scorer. (57 Matches).

Mutual Respect? Both Peter & Phil have expressed a great deal of mutual admiration Photo: Lawrence Lustig/PDC

Four: Peter Wright (Win rate 33%)

Snakebite is the first in our list to claim wins more than a third of his encounters with the Stoke-on-Trent legend. Wright lost nine-out-of-ten of their early encounters, the tenth was a draw! Wrighty finally claimed victory in the, non ranked, Dubai Masters. Weeks later Peter gained an important win, the Qtr final of the UK Open of 2015. After this point The Scottish thrower earned more, and more, successes, until he too was winning around half of his tussles with Taylor. These wins partially offset the early defeats and enabled a fine record to be built. (33 Matches).

Three: Micheal Van Gerwyn (43.33%)

MVG‘s rumbles with The Power cover more than a decade and chart Micheal’s rise, slump and return. Early on the Dutchman did well and claimed two, from three, of their early encounters. As was often the case, during this period, Phil learnt, adapted and defeated Micheal on the next fifteen occasions that they met. In 2012 things started to turn.

Phil Taylor and Michael van Gerwen
From early days to later years. Over a decade of battles between The Power & MVG.

MVG began to get the upper hand and steadily improved his record against the player against whom he will always be compared. He racked up more than twenty wins between 2012 and 2017. Even with this superb spell of form he could not totally conquer The Power. Phil used his experience, professionalism and matchplay skills to limit the damage and score major wins during this time. Most memorable were Taylor’s 2013 World Championship (final) win, known to the author as ‘darting rope-e-dope’, and the time defying demolition of Micheal in the 2016 Matchplay. Still Mighty Mike clocks over 40% and in the modern era! (60 matches).

Two: Rod Harrington (43.75%)

Harrington is a very unusual player in this list. The former World Master dominated Taylor during their early rivalries. Indeed, Rod claimed six out of eight initial skirmishes. Also unusually he claimed most of those wins in finals and semi finals. The Power then reversed the tables and completed a series of heavier and heavier defeats upon Harrington. During their last eight encounter it was Phil who clocked up a seven-one run. Again, most of these encounters were finals or later stage matches.

Although their rivalry does not include as many matches, as some, Taylor vs Harrington was conducted during a tough time for the sport and mainly at the highest level. To get even close, to a 50% record, is a remarkable effort and shared by only one other. (16 Matches).

One: Peter Evison: (Win rate 50%)

The Fenn Tiger sits alone in our table of those who fought ‘The Power’. Over a thirteen year time-span the two clashed in the famed World Masters, the early PDC Lada Masters, The World Matchplay and The World Grand Prix.

So, across all formats, both BDO and PDC events, and during different stages of their careers. Peter Evison comes out even.

Each player handed the other a terrible beating, or two, with Evison’s 8-1 demolition of Taylor, at his ‘home’ venue in Blackpool, at the World Matchplay being his high-point.

Later, Taylor (once more!) turned the tide and inflicted heavy defeats of his own. But, despite his best efforts, ‘The Power’ was unable to was unable to best ‘The Tiger’ overall. (8 Matches).


To illustrate how difficult it was to get even a single win, vs The Power, here are the six who suffered most his hands.

Nigel Heydon80100.00%
Shayne Burgess110100.00%
Kevin McDine110100.00%
Dennis Smith140100.00%
Alan Tabern160100.00%
Roland Scholten
See Roland’s full record & get more info at dartsdatabase.